Please wait a minute...
J4  2012, Vol. 46 Issue (1): 163-169    DOI: 10.3785/j.issn.1008-973X.2012.01.26
    
Collaborative evaluation method for product concept based on
Choquet integral and evidence theory
AN Xiang-hua, FENG Yi-xiong, TAN Jian-rong
State Key Laboratory of Fluid Power Transmission and Control, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou 310027, China
Download:   PDF(0KB) HTML
Export: BibTeX | EndNote (RIS)      

Abstract  

The α-cut fuzzy evaluation method was applied to evaluate each criterion of product design concept. A criteria aggregation model based on Choquet integral operator was introduced for product design concept holistic evaluation considering interrelations and nonlinear combination between those evaluation criteria. Then preference comparison matrices were constructed and the algorithm for priority of fuzzy complementary judgment matrix was adopted, so that priority ordering was acquired. Aiming at cross-function experts’ evaluation opinions with discrepancy, the improved evidence theory was utilized to synthesize each expert decision result of product design concepts preference sorting. The relatively stable and harmonious decision-making result for product design concept evaluation was obtained. A large scale deep cooling air-separating equipment concepts evaluation and selection process  was provided as a practical case in order to illustrate the application and validation of the method through simulation and computation.



Published: 22 February 2012
CLC:  TH 122  
Cite this article:

AN Xiang-hua, FENG Yi-xiong, TAN Jian-rong. Collaborative evaluation method for product concept based on
Choquet integral and evidence theory. J4, 2012, 46(1): 163-169.

URL:

http://www.zjujournals.com/eng/10.3785/j.issn.1008-973X.2012.01.26     OR     http://www.zjujournals.com/eng/Y2012/V46/I1/163


基于Choquet积分与证据理论的
产品方案协同评价方法

利用α-截集的模糊评价法对产品方案的各个准则进行评价.考虑到不同评价准则之间具有关联性和非线性组合关系,提出基于Choquet模糊积分的产品方案总体评价合成模型.构建偏好度比较矩阵,采用模糊互补排序算法确定产品方案的优劣排序关系.针对不同领域的评价专家会给出不一致的排序结果,利用改进的证据理论来集结各专家的评价意见并得到相对稳定与协调的方案优劣排序结果.以大型空气分离设备的方案评价与选择作为实例,对该方法进行检验,证实了该方法的可行性与有效性.

[1] THURSTON D L, CARNAHAN J V. Fuzzy ratings and utility analysis in preliminary design evaluation of multiple attributes[J]. Journal of Mechanical Design, 1992, 114(4): 648-658.
[2] 周庆忠,曾慧娥.机械产品设计方案的灰色模糊综合评价[J].机械设计与制造,2001,38(3): 6-8.
ZHOU Qingzhong, ZENG Huie. The grey fuzzy synthetic assessment on the design scheme of mechanical production[J]. Machinery Design and Manufacture, 2001, 38(3): 6-8.
[3] 张雪平,殷国富.基于层次灰色关联的产品绿色度评价研究[J].中国电机工程学报,2005, 25(17):78-82.
ZHANG Xueping, YIN Guofu. Research on evaluation method of product green defree based on layered grey relation [J]. Proceedings of the CSEE, 2005, 25(17): 78-82.
[4] AYAG Z, ZDEMIR R G. A hybrid approach to concept selection through fuzzy analytic network process[J].Computers and Industrial Engineering, 2009, 56(1): 368-379.
[5] ZHAI L Y, KHOO L P, ZHONG Z W. Design concept evaluation in product development using rough sets and grey relation analysis [J]. Expert Systems with Applications, 2009, 36(3): 7072-7079.
[6] 胡良明,徐诚,方峻. CBR技术在枪械方案设计专家系统中的应用[J]. 系统仿真学报, 2007,19(4):772-775.
HU Liangming, XU Cheng, FANG Jun. Casebased reasoning and its application in scheme design of small arms expert system[J]. Journal of System Simulation, 2007, 19(4): 772-775.
[7] HUANG Hongzhong, BO Ruifeng, CHEN Wei. An integrated computational intelligence approach to product concept generation and evaluation[J]. Mechanism and Machine Theory, 2006, 41(5): 567-583.
[8] 古莹奎,杨振宇.概念设计方案评价的模糊多准则决策模型[J].计算机集成制造系统, 2007, 13(8): 1504-1510.
GU Yingkui, YANG Zhenyu. Fuzzy multicriteria decisionmaking model for conceptual design candidates evaluation [J]. Computer Integrated Manufacturing Systems, 2007, 13(8): 1504-1510.
[9] 方辉,谭建荣,殷国富,等.基于改进不确定语言多属性决策的设计方案评价[J].计算机集成制造系,2009,15(7):1257-1261.
FANG Hui, TAN Jianrong, YIN Guofu, et al. Design scheme evaluation based on improved uncertainlanguage multiattribute decisionmaking method [J]. Computer Integrated Manufacturing Systems, 2009, 15(7): 1257-1261.
[10] GENG Xiuli, CHU Xuening, ZHANG Zaifang. A new integrated design concept evaluation approach based on vague sets [J]. Expert Systems with Applications, 2010, 37(9): 6629-6638.
[11] 邓军,余忠华,吴昭同. 基于信息熵的概念设计的质量评价[J]. 浙江大学学报:工学版,2009,43(8):1480-1484.
DENG Jun, YU Zhonghua, WU Zhaotong. Quality evaluation of quality design based on entropy [J]. Journal of Zhejiang University: Engineering Science, 2009, 43(8):1480-1484.
[12] MUROFUSHI T, SUGENO M. A theory of fuzzy measures, representation, the Choquet integral and null sets [J]. Journal of Mathematical Analysis and Applications, 1991, 159(2): 532-549.
[13] 张朝勇,王卓甫,邢会歌.基于Choquet模糊积分的工程投标风险评估方法[J].土木工程学报,2007,40(10):98-104.
ZHANG Chaoyong, WANG Zhuofu, XING Huige. Risk assessment system for bidding of construction projects based on Choquet fuzzy integral[J]. China Civil Engineering Journal, 2007, 40(10): 98-104.
[14] 王继奎.基于模糊积分的客户满意度综合评价算法设计[J]. 甘肃科学学报,2009,21(1):101-104.
WANG Jikui. Design of a general algorithm for comprehensive evaluation of customer’s satisfaction based on fuzzy integral [J]. Journal of Gansu Sciences, 2009, 21(1): 101-104.
[15] 丁莹,李文辉,范静涛,等. 基于Choquet模糊积分的运动目标检测算法[J].电子学报,2010,38 (2): 263-268.
DING Ying, LI Wenhui, FAN Jingtao, et al. A moving object detection algorithm base on Choquet integral[J]. Chinese Journal of Electronics, 2010, 38 (2): 263-268.
[16] GRABISCH M. korder additive discrete fuzzy measures and their representation [J]. Fuzzy Sets and Systems, 1997, 92(2):167-189.
[17] MARICHAL J L. Entropy of discrete Choquet capacities[J]. European Journal of Operational Research, 2002, 137(3): 612-624.
[18] 章玲,周德群. 基于k可加模糊测度的多属性决策分析[J].管理科学学报,2008,11(6):18-24.
ZHANG Ling, ZHOU Dequn. Multicriteria decision making based on kadditive fuzzy measures [J].Journal of Management Sciences in China, 2008, 11(6): 18-24.
[19] 许永平,石福丽,杨峰,等.基于模糊积分的潜艇作战能力评估方法[J].计算机仿真,2009,26(9):19-23.
XU Yongping, SHI Fuli, YANG Feng, et al. A submarine operational capability evaluation approach based on fuzzy integral[J]. Computer Simulation, 2009, 26(9): 19-23.
[20] SAAD I, HAMMADI S, BENREJEB M, et al. Choquet integral for criteria aggregation in the flexible jobshop scheduling problems [J]. Mathematics and Computers in Simulation, 2008, 76(5/6): 447-462.
[21] BYKZKAN G, RUAN D. Choquet integral based aggregation approach to software development risk assessment [J]. Information Sciences, 2010, 180(3): 441-451.
[22] ZHANG Dongfeng, ZHANG Jinlong, LAI K, et al. An novel approach to supplier selection based on vague sets group decision[J]. Expert Systems with Applications, 2009, 36(5): 9557-9563.
[23] 徐泽水.模糊互补判断矩阵排序的一种算法[J].系统工程学报,2001,16(4):311-314.
XU Zeshui. Algorithm for priority of fuzzy complementary judgment matrix [J]. Journal of Systems Engineering, 2001, 16(4): 311-314.
[24] SHAFER G. A mathematical theory of evidence[M].  Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1976.
[25] 吕文红,吴祈宗,郭银景.基于DS证据理论的群决策专家意见集结方法[J]. 运筹与管理,2005,14 (2):10-25.
LV Wenhong, WU Qizong, GUO Yinjing. The expertise aggregation method in group decision making based on the DS evidence theory [J]. Operations Research and Management Science,2005, 14 (2): 10-25.
[26] WU  Desheng. Supplier selection in a fuzzy group setting: a method using grey related analysis and DempsterShafer theory[J]. Expert Systems with Applications, 2009, 36(5): 8892-8899.
[27] FU Chao, YANG Shanlin. The group consensus based evidential reasoning approach for multiple attributive group decision analysis [J].European Journal of Operational Research, 2010, 206(3): 601-608.
[28] MALCOLM J B. A method of aggregation in DS/AHP for group decisionmaking with the nonequivalent importance of individuals in the group [J]. Computers and Operations Research, 2005, 32(7): 1881-1896.

[1] YANG Wei, ZHANG Xiu-feng, YANG Can-jun, WU Hai-jie. Design of a lower extremity exoskeleton
based on 5-bar human machine model
[J]. J4, 2014, 48(3): 430-435.
[2] LIU Zheng, GU Xin-jian, PAN Kai, YANG Qing-hai. Research on TRIZ-based product eco-design
——Integrating rule-based reasoning and case-based reasoning
[J]. J4, 2014, 48(3): 436-444.
[3] JI Xiang, GU Xin-jian, DAI Feng, LIU Zheng. BioTRIZ-based product innovative design process[J]. J4, 2014, 48(1): 35-41.
[4] LIN Xiao-hua, FENG Yi-xiong, TAN Jian-rong. Intervals prediction of system reliability parameters based on immune optimization[J]. J4, 2013, 47(6): 1013-1021.
[5] YING Zheng, WANG Qing, LI Jiang-xiong, KE Ying-lin,SUN Wen-bo,HAN Yong-wei. Motion data integration and monitoring of digital assembly system of aircraft[J]. J4, 2013, 47(5): 761-767.
[6] YING Zheng, ZHANG Ming, WANG Qing, KE Ying-lin. Modeling and simulation of wear for alignment mechanism of
large aircraft component
[J]. J4, 2013, 47(2): 209-215.
[7] LIU Xi-ze, QI Guo-ning, FU Jian-zhong, FAN Bei-bei, XU Jing. A design process model of integrated morphological matrix and
conflict resolving principles
[J]. J4, 2012, 46(12): 2243-2251.
[8] HUANG Xue-mei, ZHANG Lei-an, WEI Xiu-ting. D-MFAC algorithm control of megawatt wind turbine
blade static loading process
[J]. J4, 2012, 46(12): 2280-2284.
[9] . Constraint model and calculating method by evolutionary game algorithm for product conceptual design[J]. J4, 2012, 46(3): 533-541.
[10] LUO Cheng-dui, FENG Yi-xiong, TAN Jian-rong, AN Xiang-hua. Group multicriteria solving for product design scheme based on semantic PROMETHEE[J]. J4, 2012, 46(3): 524-532.
[11] MA Zhi-yong, QIU Qing-ying, FENG Pei-en, SHEN Men-hong, ZENG Ling-bin. Concept system and application method of mechanical symmetry[J]. J4, 2010, 44(12): 2354-2359.
[12] ZHANG Xiu-Fen, ZHANG Shu-Wei, YI Guo-Dong. Multi-granularity and hierarchy disassemblability evaluation model
and methodology for products
[J]. J4, 2010, 44(3): 581-588.
[13] JIANG Wei-Guang, WU Jian-Wei, TUN Can, et al. Ontology based product knowledge integration[J]. J4, 2009, 43(10): 1801-1807.
[14] LIU Hai-Jiang, JI Yang-Jian, QI Guo-Ning, et al. Product integrated design knowledge model supporting multidisciplinary design optimization[J]. J4, 2009, 43(10): 1841-1847.
[15] FU Yu-Ying, BO Xiao-Hong, WANG Zheng-Xiao. Supply chain multiobjective optimization based on fuzzy cooperative game[J]. J4, 2009, 43(09): 1644-1648.