Spatial Proximity Advantage, Internet Medical Services and Hierarchical Medical System: A Survey on the Choice of First Visit Medical Institutions for Urban Residents in Yangtze River Delta
Xu Zhaopeng1,2, Zhang Lufa1,3
1.School of International and Public Affairs, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai 200030, China 2.School of Emergency Management, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai 200030, China 3.Institute of Healthy Yangtze River Delta, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai 200030, China
Abstract：The comprehensive establishment of a mature and perfect hierarchical medical system is a key component of the Healthy China Strategy, and the key to implementing this hierarchical medical system lies in strengthening primary healthcare institutions (i.e. strengthening grassroots). Enhancing the accessibility of primary healthcare resources is one of the most important measures for strengthening the grassroots. Although the negative effect of distance on the patients’ choice has been widely verified in previous studies, whether strengthening the spatial proximity advantage of primary healthcare institutions can enhance their competitiveness has not been sufficiently explored due to the strong preference for higher-level hospitals in China. In addition, the explosive growth of Internet-based medical services in recent years, especially during the epidemic, has provided new possibilities for the promotion of the hierarchical medical system, but the effect may be twofold. Moreover, previous studies have mainly emphasized the induced effect of information about the impact of Internet-based medical services on patients’ choices, and the measurement validity of the core variables may be insufficient. As two new variables in China’s healthcare landscape in recent years, the burgeoning grassroots and the explosive growth of Internet-based medical services not only have interactive relationship with each other, but are also possible answers to shaping an efficient and well-organized healthcare system in China. Therefore, this paper therefore explores the impact of spatial proximity advantage of healthcare institutions and Internet-based medical services on residents’ choice of first visit, and the possible moderating role and the heterogeneity. The data for this study come from 15,481 valid questionnaires obtained from a multi-stage stratified sampling of 41 cities in the Yangtze River Delta, and the empirical analysis mainly uses methods such as multinomial logit regression. The results of the study show that (1) even in the current context of low trust in primary healthcare institutions, the spatial proximity advantage of each type of healthcare institution still significantly increases its attractiveness to residents for first visits. Even the competitive edge generated by the spatial proximity advantage of the primary healthcare institutions is greater than that of the tertiary hospitals. (2) Internet-based medical services significantly increase the rate of residents choosing tertiary hospitals as a substitute for primary healthcare institutions or secondary hospitals for their first visit, but this substitution effect does not show up in secondary hospitals versus primary health care institution. In the future, secondary hospitals may face the dilemma of “sandwich layer” in the promotion of the hierarchical medical system. (3) Internet-based medical services can strengthen the competitiveness generated by the spatial proximity advantage of each type of healthcare institution. Internet-based medical services and physical medical services may not necessarily be a substitute for each other, but may also promote each other. (4) Different types of Internet-based medical services have different effects on residents’ choice of first visit, and “online reservation + telehealth” has a significant positive effect on increasing the first-visit rate in primary health care institutions and strengthening their spatial proximity advantage. Therefore, this paper proposes that improving the primary healthcare service network and using suitable Internet-based medical services to connect high-level hospitals with primary healthcare institutions will likely be a new solution to improving the hierarchical medical system and the construction of an integrated healthcare service system.
徐召鹏, 张录法. 空间邻近优势、互联网医疗与分级诊疗[J]. 浙江大学学报(人文社会科学版), 2025, 55(3): 60-75.
Xu Zhaopeng, Zhang Lufa. Spatial Proximity Advantage, Internet Medical Services and Hierarchical Medical System: A Survey on the Choice of First Visit Medical Institutions for Urban Residents in Yangtze River Delta. JOURNAL OF ZHEJIANG UNIVERSITY, 2025, 55(3): 60-75.
1 《全国卫生与健康大会19日至20日在京召开》，2016年8月20日，http：//www.gov.cn/xinwen/2016-08/20/content_5101024.htm，2024年12月20日。 2 《中共中央、国务院印发〈“健康中国2030”规划纲要〉》，2016年10月25日，https：//www.gov.cn/zhengce/202203/content_3635233.htm，2024年12月20日。 3 习近平：《决胜全面建成小康社会 夺取新时代中国特色社会主义伟大胜利——在中国共产党第十九次全国代表大会上的报告》，2017年10月27日，http：//www.gov.cn/zhuanti/2017-10/27/content_5234876.htm，2024年10月20日。 4 Wang Y.， Sun L. & Hou J.， “Hierarchical medical system based on big data and mobile Internet： a new strategic choice in health care，” JMIR Medical Informatics， Vol. 5， No. 3 （2017）， https：//doi.org/10.2196/medinform.6799. 5 Goldfield N.， Gnani S. & Majeed A.， “Primary care in the United States： profiling performance in primary care in the United States，” BMJ， Vol. 326， No. 7392 （2003）， pp. 744-747. 6 王晓磊、吕梦琦：《落实分级诊疗关键要“强基层”》，2015年9月17日，https：//www.gov.cn/zhengce/2015-09/11/content_2929911.htm，2024年12月20日。 7 Lin C.， Abdul S. S. & Clinciu D. L. et al.， “Empowering village doctors and enhancing rural healthcare using cloud computing in a rural area of mainland China，” Computer Methods and Programs in Biomedicine， Vol. 113， No. 2 （2014）， pp. 585-592. 8 国家卫生健康委统计信息中心编著：《2018年全国第六次卫生服务统计调查报告》，北京：人民卫生出版社，2021年。 9 詹佳佳、傅虹桥：《医院声誉、空间距离与患者就医选择——基于病案首页数据的分析》，《经济学（季刊）》2022年第1期，第343-364页。 10 Li L. & Fu H.， “China’s health care system reform： progress and prospects，” The International Journal of Health Planning and Management， Vol. 32， No. 3 （2017）， pp. 240-253. 11 张晓旭：《〈2022互联网医院报告〉发布：创新医疗质量建设，促进行业进入服务收费时代》，2022年11月15日，https：//www.vbdata.cn/1518881918，2024年12月20日。 12 国家发展改革委、中央网信办：《关于推进“上云用数赋智”行动 培育新经济发展实施方案》，2020年4月10日，http：//www.gov.cn/zhengce/zhengceku/2020-04/10/content_5501163.htm，2024年12月20日。 13 Kim H. G.， Ahn M. E. & Choi Y. A. et al.， “Fifteen-year experience with telemedicine services in Gangwon Province in Korea，” Healthcare Informatics Research， Vol. 21， No. 4 （2015）， pp. 283-291. 14 López C.， Valenzuela J. I. & Calderón J. E. et al.， “A telephone survey of patient satisfaction with realtime telemedicine in a rural community in Colombia，” Journal of Telemedicine and Telecare， Vol. 17， No. 2 （2011）， pp. 83-87. 15 Marcin J. P.， Shaikh U. & Steinhorn R. H.， “Addressing health disparities in rural communities using telehealth，” Pediatric Research， Vol. 79， No. 1-2 （2016）， pp. 169-176. 16 Jaglal S. B.， Haroun V. A. & Salbach N. M. et al.， “Increasing access to chronic disease self-management programs in rural and remote communities using telehealth，” Telemedicine and e-Health， Vol. 19， No. 6 （2013）， pp. 467-473. 17 He C.， Zhou Q. & Chen W. et al.， “Using an Internet-based hospital to address maldistribution of health care resources in rural areas of Guangdong Province， China： retrospective and descriptive study，” JMIR Medical Informatics， Vol. 6， No. 4 （2018）， https：//doi.org/10.2196/medinform.9495. 18 Xie X.， Lin L. & Fan S. et al.， “Internet hospital in China： a cross-sectional survey，” The Lancet， Vol. 390 （2017）， https：//doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736（17）33178-1. 19 Li Y. B.， James L. & McKibben J.， “Trust between physicians and patients in the e-health era，” Technology in Society， Vol. 46 （2016）， pp. 28-34. 20 Manhattan Research， “New study shows Internet directing consumers’ choice of health services and products，” 2012-03-01， http：//manhattanresearch.com/News-and-Events/Press-Releases/consumers-internet-health-services， 2024-12-20. 21 Lee C.， Gray S. W. & Lewis N.， “Internet use leads cancer patients to be active health care consumers，” Patient Education and Counseling， Vol. 81 （2010）， pp. S63-S69. 22 Ouyaba A.T. & Kesim S. ?.， “The effect of the Internet on decision-making during pregnancy： a systematic review，” Archives of Women’s Mental Health， Vol. 24， No. 2 （2021）， pp. 205-215. 23 Chiu M. P.， “An investigation of the questions posted on medical consultation websites，” Health Information & Libraries Journal， Vol. 33， No. 4 （2016）， pp. 283-294. 24 沓钰淇、傅虹桥：《网络口碑对患者就医选择的影响——基于在线医生评论的实证研究》，《管理评论》2021年第11期，第185-198页。 25 Arora P.， Singh N. & Visaria A.， “Healthcare costs， choice of providers and patient satisfaction： survey evidence from India，” Econometric Society， Vol. 21， No. 3 （2023）， pp. 593-616. 26 陈昕欣、封进：《医保报销待遇与患者异地就医选择——基于空间距离、医院等级和医保待遇的分析》，《数量经济技术经济研究》2024年第4期，第131-152页。 27 Liu Y.， Kong Q. & de Bekker-Grob E. W.， “Public preferences for health care facilities in rural China： a discrete choice experiment，” Social Science & Medicine （1982）， Vol. 237 （2019）， https：//doi.org/10.1016/j.socscimed.2019.112396. 28 荣旖旎、欧阳文静：《公路可达性对农村居民县城就医行为的影响——来自村庄月度数据》，《经济地理》2024年第3期，第45-54页。 29 Chen Q.， Xu D. & Fu H. et al.， “Distance effects and home bias in patient choice on the Internet： evidence from an online healthcare platform in China，” China Economic Review， Vol. 72 （2022）， https：//doi.org/10.1016/j.chieco.2022.101757. 30 马红梅、代亭亭：《工作时间长度对劳动者健康的影响——基于CFPS （2020）数据的实证研究》，《西北人口》2022年第6期，第99-112页。 31 Shroff P. L.， Hayes R. W. & Padmanabhan P. et al.， “Internet usage by parents prior to seeking care at a pediatric emergency department： observational study，” Interactive Journal of Medical Research， Vol. 6， No. 2 （2017）， https：//doi.org/10.2196/ijmr.5075. 32 刘宸、周向红：《互联网医疗信息溢出与中国居民就诊选择——基于CHNS混合截面数据的实证研究》，《公共管理学报》2017年第4期，第78-90页。 33 Li G.， Han C. & Liu P.， “Does Internet use affect medical decisions among older adults in China？ evidence from CHARLS，” Healthcare， Vol. 10， No. 1 （2022）， https：//doi.org/10.3390/healthcare10010060. 34 Wang L.， Cheng Z. & Ye L. et al.， “The association between Internet use and the choice of medical institution among Chinese older adults，” BMC Geriatrics， Vol. 24， No. 1 （2024）， https：//doi.org/10.1186/s12877-024-04994-3. 35 Avdic D.， Moscelli G. & Pilny A. et al.， “Subjective and objective quality and choice of hospital： evidence from maternal care services in Germany，” Journal of Health Economics， Vol. 68 （2019）， https：//doi.org/10.1016/j.jhealeco.2019.102229. 36 Rice T.， Rosenau P. & Unruh L. Y. et al.， “United States of America： health system review introduction，” Health Systems in Transition ， Vol. 15， No. 3 （2013）， pp. 231-232. 37 Kominski G. F. （ed.）， Changing the U.S. Health Care System： Key Issues in Health Services Policy and Management， 4th edition， San Francisco： Jossey-Bass， 2013. 38 Wagstaff A. & Lindelow M.， “Can insurance increase financial risk？” Journal of Health Economics， Vol. 27， No. 4 （2008）， pp. 990-1005. 39 De Santis M.， De Luca C. & Quattrocchi T. et al.， “Use of the Internet by women seeking information about potentially teratogenic agents，” European Journal of Obstetrics & Gynecology and Reproductive Biology， Vol. 151， No. 2 （2010）， pp. 154-157. 40 Zhou M.， Zhao S. & Fu M.， “Supply-induced demand for medical services under price regulation： evidence from hospital expansion in China，” China Economic Review， Vol. 68 （2021）， https：//doi.org/10.1016/j.chieco.2021.101642. 41 申梦晗、李亚青：《医疗保险干预能否缓解三级医院的“虹吸效应”？——基于某大城市的实证研究》，《公共行政评论》2021年第2期，第61-84页。 42 Zhou Z.， Zhao Y. & Shen C. et al.， “Evaluating the effect of hierarchical medical system on health seeking behavior： a difference-in-differences analysis in China，” Social Science & Medicine， Vol. 268 （2021）， https：//doi.org/10.1016/j.socscimed.2020.113372. 43 Yang Q.， Zhang H. & Yu M. et al.， “Chinese minority perceives the doctor-patient relationship differently： a cultural and economic interpretation，” Frontiers in Public Health， Vol. 7 （2019）， https：//doi.org/10.3389/fpubh.2019.00330. 44 Zhou M.， Zhao L. & Kong N. et al.， “Factors influencing behavior intentions to telehealth by Chinese elderly： an extended TAM model，” International Journal of Medical Informatics， Vol. 126 （2019）， pp. 118-127. 45 山西省卫生健康委员会、山西省药品监督管理局：《关于停止互联网医疗首诊的公告》，2023年2月8日，http：//wjw.shanxi.gov.cn/tzgg/gsgg/202302/t20230208_7945579.shtml，2024年12月20日。
2025, Vol. 55 
